Best Hotels in New York, New York with Top Reviews

Top-rated properties including rising stars, consistent performers, and algorithmically chosen picks

Explore curated picks for New York, New York:

How We Select

This list is generated using our proprietary algorithm that analyzes guest reviews, rating consistency, value metrics, and verified hotel data. Hotels are updated automatically to ensure accuracy and relevance.

Criteria: Minimum 8.5/10 rating, consistent review patterns, and verified classifications (Rising Star, Consistent, Featured).

TOP RATED

Favorite Based on Reviews

Top-rated properties curated from our rising stars, consistent picks, and featured selections

Hotel Name Type Rating Location Info
Hotel: Hazelton Saint James Type: Top Rated Rating:
5.00
Location:
Upper West Side, New York, New York
Info:
Category Not classified
Hotel: Kolping House site → Type: Top Rated Rating:
4.90
Location:
Upper West Side, New York, New York
Info:
Category Not classified
Hotel: The Hotel Chelsea site → Type: Consistent Pick Rating:
4.80
Location:
City Center, New York, New York
Info:
Category Not classified
Hotel: Freeman Residences NYC site → Type: Top Rated Rating:
4.80
Location:
SoHo, New York, New York
Info:
Category Not classified
Hotel: The Phillips Club site → Type: Top Rated Rating:
4.80
Location:
Upper West Side, New York, New York
Info:
Category Not classified
Hotel: The Wall Street Hotel site → Type: Consistent Pick Rating:
4.70
Location:
Downtown, New York, New York
Info:
Category Not classified
Hotel: Little Charlie Hotel site → Type: Consistent Pick Rating:
4.70
Location:
SoHo, New York, New York
Info:
Category Not classified
Hotel: Artezen Hotel site → Type: Consistent Pick Rating:
4.70
Location:
Downtown, New York, New York
Info:
Category Not classified
Hotel: Placemakr Wall Street site → Type: Consistent Pick Rating:
4.70
Location:
Downtown, New York, New York
Info:
Category Not classified
Hotel: NobleDEN Hotel site → Type: Consistent Pick Rating:
4.70
Location:
SoHo, New York, New York
Info:
Category Not classified
Hotel: Hotel Riu Plaza Manhattan Times Square site → Type: Consistent Pick Rating:
4.70
Location:
Upper West Side, New York, New York
Info:
Category Not classified
Hotel: Mandarin Oriental, New York site → Type: Consistent Pick Rating:
4.60
Location:
Upper West Side, New York, New York
Info:
Category Not classified
Hotel: Conrad New York Downtown Type: Consistent Pick Rating:
4.60
Location:
Downtown, New York, New York
Info:
Category Not classified
Hotel: Staypineapple, An Artful Hotel, Midtown New York site → Type: Consistent Pick Rating:
4.60
Location:
City Center, New York, New York
Info:
Category Not classified
Hotel: LUMA Hotel Times Square site → Type: Consistent Pick Rating:
4.60
Location:
City Center, New York, New York
Info:
Category Not classified
Hotel: Untitled at 3 Freeman Alley site → Type: Consistent Pick Rating:
4.60
Location:
SoHo, New York, New York
Info:
Category Not classified
Hotel: The St. Regis New York Type: Consistent Pick Rating:
4.50
Location:
City Center, New York, New York
Info:
Category Not classified
Hotel: The Plaza site → Type: Consistent Pick Rating:
4.50
Location:
Midtown, New York, New York
Info:
Category Not classified
Hotel: The Bowery Hotel site → Type: Consistent Pick Rating:
4.50
Location:
City Center, New York, New York
Info:
Category Not classified
Hotel: Refinery Hotel site → Type: Consistent Pick Rating:
4.50
Location:
City Center, New York, New York
Info:
Category Not classified
Hotel: The New York EDITION Type: Consistent Pick Rating:
4.50
Location:
City Center, New York, New York
Info:
Category Not classified
Hotel: EVEN Hotel New York - Times Square South by IHG Type: Consistent Pick Rating:
4.50
Location:
City Center, New York, New York
Info:
Category 5 Stars (Luxury)
Hotel: The Peninsula New York Type: Consistent Pick Rating:
4.50
Location:
City Center, New York, New York
Info:
Category Not classified
Hotel: Hard Rock Hotel New York site → Type: Consistent Pick Rating:
4.50
Location:
Midtown, New York, New York
Info:
Category Not classified
Hotel: citizenM New York Bowery Type: Consistent Pick Rating:
4.50
Location:
SoHo, New York, New York
Info:
Category Not classified
Transparency: LocalHotels.com directory has connected travelers with hotels since 1998. All hotel website listings appear free of charge. Some featured properties may include affiliate links or paid placements, which help support our independent testing and guide creation.
Plan
with AI